Users appreciate the simplicity and ease of configuring the WordPress Genesis Simple Share plugin. It is highly valued for its clean, minimal design and its efficient performance that doesn't bloat or slow down their websites. The plugin integrates seamlessly with Genesis themes and offers features like targeting custom post types and a useful live preview in the admin panel. However, there are notable drawbacks. Users express frustration over the lack of certain sharing options like Instagram, WhatsApp, and email. Additionally, issues with Pinterest image selection and minor CSS conflicts are frequently mentioned. Despite these, the community sees potential and requests further improvements, suggesting the inclusion of additional settings and social platforms.