Users appreciate the WordPress plugin for its simplicity and effectiveness in enabling select-and-share functionality similar to Medium. It allows easy sharing on major social networks and integrates seamlessly, enhancing content reach without intrusiveness. Users commend its quick setup, mobile optimization, and clean interface. However, drawbacks include lack of advanced features, such as Facebook sharing opening in a new window, share tracking, integration with Twitter handles, and toggling services on or off. Despite these, the plugin performs well, fulfilling its core purpose and driving increased traffic to users' sites.