Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) vs Carbonmade: guide for 2024

Final verdict

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) and Carbonmade cater to different audiences, each excelling in their respective domains.

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) (Overall Grade: 6.9/10)

is a robust ecommerce platform designed for businesses seeking extensive customization, scalability, and advanced ecommerce features. It offers a comprehensive suite of tools for product and inventory management, customer engagement, and marketing. Adobe Commerce is ideal for businesses looking to establish a powerful online store with the flexibility to grow and adapt to changing market needs.
Carbonmade (Overall Grade: 4.4/10)

is tailored for creatives who want to showcase their work online without the need for coding skills. It provides an easy-to-use platform with customizable layouts, making it perfect for photographers, illustrators, and designers. While it lacks ecommerce functionalities, Carbonmade excels in providing a user-friendly experience for creating and managing online portfolios.

	Overall grade: 6.9	Overall grade: 4.4
Design functionalities & templates	6.7	7.3
Ease of use	5.4	8.3
Ecommerce	9.4	0
Website Editors	7.8	7.6
Product testing options	3.9	7.2
Price	5.8	7.9
Hosting quality	8.1	6.1
Website speed optimization	6.6	5.0
Plugins/extensions and integrations	9.1	0
Marketing features	8.1	1.0
Customer support	8.3	5.8
Website security	8.4	5.8
AI capabilities	7.7	0
User Management	8.0	2.8

Best for ecommerce

9.4

Verdict

: Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) is a comprehensive ecommerce solution, whereas Carbonmade is not designed for ecommerce functionalities.

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

: This platform is a powerhouse for ecommerce, offering advanced product and inventory management, efficient order processing, and robust customer management. It supports multiple brands and markets, provides developer tools for customization, and ensures scalability with cloud-native solutions. Adobe Commerce is ideal for businesses looking to establish and manage successful online stores.
Carbonmade

: Tailored for creatives, Carbonmade excels in providing customizable layouts for online portfolios. However, it does not offer any ecommerce features, making it unsuitable for businesses looking to sell products online.

Best for informational & business websites

7.4

5.9

Verdict

: Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) is a more robust choice for informational business websites due to its extensive customization options, scalability, and comprehensive support resources. Carbonmade, while user-friendly and ideal for creatives, lacks the advanced features and flexibility needed for more complex business websites.

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

: Adobe Commerce, formerly known as Magento, offers a versatile platform suitable for both B2B and B2C businesses. It provides extensive customization options, AI-driven personalization, and supports multiple brands and markets. The platform includes developer tools for customization, ensuring scalability with cloud-native solutions. Integration with Adobe Experience Cloud enhances customer insights, making it a powerful choice for businesses looking to create a comprehensive online presence. With a score of 7.4, Adobe Commerce is well-suited for informational business websites that require advanced features and scalability.
Carbonmade

: Carbonmade is designed specifically for creatives who want to showcase their work online without the need for coding skills. It offers fully customizable layouts perfect for photographers, illustrators, motion designers, graphic designers, and copywriters. Carbonmade provides an easy and fast way to create and manage online portfolios, featuring pre-designed templates and various tools. However, with a score of 5.9, Carbonmade is less suitable for more complex informational business websites, as it lacks the advanced features and flexibility offered by Adobe Commerce.

Detailed comparison

6.7

7.3

🏆

Winner: Carbonmade.

For creatives looking for an easy-to-use platform with a high degree of customization, Carbonmade is the better choice.

Adobe Commerce, formerly Magento, prioritizes flexibility over pre-built templates. While it offers a limited selection of base themes, users can access third-party themes for customization. Theme options are highly adaptable, allowing changes to layouts, colors, fonts, and the creation of custom page layouts. The platform provides a powerful theme framework for comprehensive control, including frontend editing for basic adjustments. Experienced developers can employ custom code (HTML, CSS, Javascript) for unique designs and advanced functionalities.

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) Themes

Carbonmade does not have templates; the platform creates a personalized portfolio website based on the inputs of the users. It offers a high degree of customization flexibility tailored for creatives, enabling personalized, profession-specific layouts, responsive designs across devices, and support for unlimited uploads, including 4K videos. It provides a plethora of premade blocks and layouts for easy, drag-and-drop website design, along with specific features for various creative professions. Unlimited layout possibilities, gallery slideshows, and comprehensive design features such as SEO optimization, custom logos, and video backgrounds enhance user experience and portfolio presentation.

Wix Themes

Get a head start on website creation with AI

Create a custom website tailored to your business needs 10X faster with 10Web AI Website Builder!

Generate Your Website

No credit card required

5.4

8.3

🏆 Winner: Carbonmade

. Scoring an impressive 8.3, Carbonmade is designed with user-friendliness in mind, making it an excellent choice for creatives who want to showcase their work without needing any coding skills. Adobe Commerce, with a score of 5.4, offers extensive customization and scalability but comes with a steeper learning curve, making it less accessible for beginners.

Learning Resources

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce

. Adobe Commerce provides a comprehensive array of learning resources, including videos, tutorials, and instructor-led courses, catering to various user roles and proficiency levels. Carbonmade also offers helpful video tutorials and a help center, but Adobe Commerce’s extensive resources give it the edge.

Learn more about Adobe Commerce’s learning resources

Learn more about Carbonmade’s learning resources

9.4

Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) is a powerhouse in the ecommerce sector, offering a comprehensive suite of tools for businesses of all sizes. Its features include advanced product and inventory management, efficient order processing, and robust customer management. Carbonmade, on the other hand, is tailored for creatives looking to showcase their portfolios and does not offer any ecommerce functionalities.


Ecommerce themes and templates	7.5	0.0
Product page customization	9.0	0.0
Payment processing and commissions	7.8	0.0
POS capabilities	7.0	0.0
Payment gateways	8.5	0.0
Product numbers	7.5	0.0
Additional ecommerce features	8.0	0.0

Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) ecommerce features:

Product and Inventory Management
Order Management
Customer Management
Marketing and Promotions
Payment Processing
Multi-Channel Commerce

Adobe Commerce add a product

Carbonmade ecommerce features:

Carbonmade does not provide any ecommerce features, as it is primarily focused on portfolio creation for creatives.

Ecommerce themes & templates

Adobe Commerce offers a comprehensive ecosystem for ecommerce themes and templates, allowing businesses to customize their online stores to meet specific branding and functionality requirements. These themes incorporate layout files, template files, translation files, and skins to define the look and feel of the store. Carbonmade does not offer any templates for ecommerce as it is not designed for such purposes.

Product page customization

Adobe Commerce provides extensive customization options for product pages, enabling businesses to enhance the user experience and tailor product displays to their specific needs. This includes customizing layouts, product attributes, images and media, dynamic content like related products and reviews, and custom product options such as configurable and bundled products. Carbonmade does not support product page customization due to its lack of ecommerce capabilities.

Payment processing

Adobe Commerce offers integrated payment solutions and commission management for seamless online transactions, alongside POS integration for omnichannel retail experiences. It supports a wide array of payment gateways, ensuring flexible and secure payment options for customers. Carbonmade does not have payment processing capabilities, as it is not designed for ecommerce.

In summary, Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) is a robust and versatile ecommerce platform suitable for businesses looking to establish and manage successful online stores. Carbonmade, while excellent for portfolio creation, does not offer any ecommerce functionalities.

7.8

7.6

🏆

Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)

. Adobe Commerce, with a score of 7.8, offers a robust ecommerce platform designed for flexibility and scalability. Its Page Builder tool provides a user-friendly, drag-and-drop interface, making it easy to manage and customize ecommerce sites. Adobe Commerce supports both B2B and B2C models and includes extensive features for product management, customer engagement, and analytics. It also offers a variety of blocks and widgets, both free and premium, for dynamic content creation, and supports extensive custom coding options for theme customization, plugin creation, and custom module development.

Carbonmade, scoring 7.6, is tailored for creatives to build personalized, professional online portfolios without requiring coding knowledge. Its editor features a drag-and-drop interface, responsive design, 4K video support, and unlimited uploads. While it offers a variety of blocks for customization, its focus on portfolio websites limits its functionality for broader website needs like ecommerce. Carbonmade’s custom code possibilities are limited to iFrame embed codes.

Mobile editor/app

🏆

Winner: None

. Both Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) and Carbonmade do not offer dedicated mobile editor apps. This means that users of these platforms will need to rely on desktop or web-based editors for managing and customizing their websites. While Adobe Commerce focuses on providing a robust ecommerce platform with extensive features for product management and customer engagement, Carbonmade is tailored for creatives looking to build personalized online portfolios. However, the lack of mobile editing capabilities may be a limitation for users who prefer to make on-the-go adjustments to their websites.

In summary, neither platform provides a mobile editor app, which could be a significant consideration for users who prioritize mobile accessibility and convenience in website management.

3.9

7.2

Overall Result

:

Carbonmade wins

. Carbonmade scores 7.2, significantly higher than Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) which scores 3.9. Carbonmade offers a trial version that allows users to test all features, making it easier for users to evaluate the platform. Adobe Commerce, while offering a demo version for testing premium features, lacks a free or trial version, which limits its accessibility for thorough testing.


Free Plan	No	No
Trial Duration	No	Yes
Testing Premium Features	Demo version available	All features within the trial period

5.8

7.9

Carbonmade offers more budget-friendly plans tailored for creatives, whereas Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) caters to enterprise-level businesses with higher pricing and more extensive features.

	Offerings	Offerings
$0-$10	No offering at this amount.	BEGINNER ($9/month): 8 Projects, Unlimited images/videos, Basic Blocks, Limited Support, 3 Navigations, SD Video, Audio Uploads. Value for Price: 5.0
$10-$20	No offering at this amount.	PRO ($12/month): 50 Projects, More Portfolio Grids, Premium Blocks, Unbranded, Portfolio statistics, Custom Pages, Private Portfolio, Unlimited images/videos, 5 Navigations, HD Video & Audio, Priority Support. Value for Price: 7.0
$20-$30	No offering at this amount.	UNLIMITED ($22/month): UNLIMITED projects/pages, Everything else, All features in PRO, Extra Karma. Value for Price: 8.5
$2000+	Adobe Commerce Pro and Managed Services ($2000/month): Adobe Commerce Pro and Managed Services are designed to deliver scalable, secure, and extensive eCommerce solutions tailored to a wide range of business demands. It offers a comprehensive set of ecommerce tools, including product and inventory management, efficient order processing, customer account management, targeted marketing capabilities, diverse payment processing options, robust security measures, and scalability to accommodate business growth. It also offers both self-hosted and cloud-hosted options, providing flexibility and optimized performance. While it does not have an AI website builder, it offers a powerful theme framework for comprehensive control, including frontend editing for basic adjustments. Experienced developers can employ custom code for unique designs and advanced functionalities.	No offering at this amount.

In some cases companies have different prices based on various components like a
location. As a result in rare cases the prices displayed here can differ from the ones you see on their
websites.

8.1

6.1

🏆

Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)

Adobe Commerce offers robust and scalable eCommerce solutions with both self-hosted and cloud-hosted options, providing flexibility and optimized performance. Carbonmade, while offering managed hosting with unlimited storage, lacks transparency in uptime statistics and data center locations, making Adobe Commerce the more reliable choice.


Do they offer hosting?	Yes, Adobe Commerce offers robust and scalable eCommerce solutions with both self-hosted and cloud-hosted options	Yes, with unlimited storage
Data Centers:	Adobe Commerce on Cloud infrastructure Leverages Amazon Web Services (AWS), Specific data center details not publicly available	Carbonmade does not disclose the locations of its data centers
Type of hosting:	Self Hosting, Managed Hosting	Managed Hosting
Uptime Guarantee:	Uptime Guarantee for Adobe Managed hosting is provided	Carbonmade does not disclose uptime statistics, neither the platform has uptime guarantee

6.6

5.0

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)

Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) outperforms Carbonmade in website speed optimization due to its comprehensive strategies and focus on Core Web Vitals improvements.


Focus	CDN, Database optimization, Caching, Indexing	No specific information provided
Performance Tools	Google Lighthouse, PageSpeed Insights	Not specified
Key Strategies	CDN, Database optimization, Caching, Indexing	Not specified
Load Times	Varies widely, dependent on optimization	Varies depending on optimization
Page Speed Scores Range	Scores vary; influenced by plugins, images	Varies depending on optimization
Core Web Vitals Improvement	Emphasis on LCP, FID, CLS improvements	Not specified

Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) employs a variety of strategies to enhance website speed, including the use of Content Delivery Networks (CDNs), database optimization, caching, and indexing. These strategies help in reducing load times and improving overall website performance. Adobe Commerce also places a strong emphasis on improving Core Web Vitals (CWV) such as Largest Contentful Paint (LCP), First Input Delay (FID), and Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS), which are crucial for user experience and SEO.

On the other hand, Carbonmade does not provide specific information on its speed optimization strategies or Core Web Vitals improvements. While it offers a user-friendly platform for creatives to showcase their work, it lacks the detailed performance optimization features that Adobe Commerce provides. This makes Adobe Commerce the better choice for users who prioritize website speed and performance.

Get a head start on website creation with AI

Create a custom website tailored to your business needs 10X faster with 10Web AI Website Builder!

Generate Your Website

No credit card required

9.1

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento).

Adobe Commerce scores 9.1, showcasing its robust ecosystem of plugins and integrations that cater to a wide range of business needs. From marketing and payment processing to shipping and analytics, Adobe Commerce offers extensive options for customization and enhancement. Carbonmade, with a score of 0, does not support any plugins or integrations, focusing instead on simplicity and ease of use for creating online portfolios.

Adobe Commerce’s extensive plugin marketplace and integration capabilities make it a superior choice for businesses looking for a highly customizable and scalable ecommerce platform.

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) Applications

Adobe Commerce marketplace

8.1

1.0

🏆

Overall Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)

. Adobe Commerce excels with its extensive marketing tools, making it ideal for businesses looking for a robust ecommerce solution. Carbonmade, while user-friendly for creatives, lacks many essential marketing features.


SEO Tools	✓	✗
Email Marketing	✓	✗
Blogging	✓	✗
Social Media Integration	Yes	Basic social network links
Analytics and Reporting	Advanced analytics and reporting tools	Basic analytics and insights
Ads and Promotions	Advanced tools for ads and promotions	✗

8.3

5.8

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

. In the comparison of Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) vs Carbonmade, Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) stands out with its comprehensive customer support. It offers 24/7 assistance through phone, email, and live chat, along with a robust knowledge base and community forums. Enterprise users benefit from dedicated account management and a global network of experts, ensuring that businesses can efficiently resolve any issues and optimize their ecommerce operations.

Carbonmade, on the other hand, provides support primarily through a ticket-based system. While response times are generally quick, the lack of live support means users may experience delays in getting immediate assistance. This limitation is reflected in its lower customer support score, making Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) the clear winner in this category.

8.4

5.8

🏆

Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)

. Adobe Commerce excels in security with a score of 8.4, offering advanced encryption, access control measures, and regular security updates to protect sensitive customer data and payment details. Its robust security infrastructure ensures that online stores are safeguarded against potential threats, making it a reliable choice for businesses that prioritize security.

Carbonmade, with a security score of 5.8, focuses primarily on simplifying the creation of portfolio websites. While it does implement comprehensive physical, electronic, and managerial safeguards to protect user data, it lacks the extensive security measures found in Adobe Commerce. This makes it less suitable for users who require high-level security for their online presence.

7.7


Personalized Design
SEO Optimization	AI-driven recommendations for better search engine visibility
Customer Behavior Analysis	Advanced analytics to understand customer preferences
Sales Predictions	AI-powered sales forecasting tools
Inventory Management	AI tools to assist in efficient inventory handling
Content Generation	AI-driven content creation and optimization

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)

. Adobe Commerce excels in AI capabilities, offering a comprehensive suite of tools that enhance various aspects of eCommerce. From personalized product recommendations and visual search to inventory management and price optimization, Adobe Commerce leverages AI to improve the shopping experience and operational efficiency. Its AI-driven content generation and SEO optimization further streamline business processes, making it a robust choice for businesses looking to harness the power of AI.

Adobe Commerce AI feature

Carbonmade, with a score of 0, does not offer any AI capabilities. It focuses on providing a simple and effective platform for creatives to showcase their work without the need for advanced AI features.

8.0

2.8

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

. When it comes to managing users, Adobe Commerce offers a comprehensive system with multiple roles and permissions, making it suitable for larger teams and complex workflows. In contrast, Carbonmade is limited to a single user, which may be restrictive for collaborative projects.

Adobe Commerce allows multiple users based on purchased licenses, with roles and permissions to control access and modifications, ensuring data security and efficient workflow.
Carbonmade allows only one user to manage and edit a website, which may be sufficient for individual creatives but not for teams.

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) User Roles and Access Levels:

Role	Description	Access Highlights
Administrator	Has full permissions to all aspects of Adobe Commerce, including global settings and data.	Full access to all settings, data, and functionalities within Adobe Commerce. Can manage other users’ roles and permissions.
Store Administrator	Responsible for the day-to-day management of the store, including products, orders, and customer service.	Access to manage products, process orders, and handle customer inquiries, but may have restricted access to sensitive global settings or data.
Design Team Member	Focuses on the aesthetic and user experience aspects of the store, working on content design and layout.	Access to content design tools and functionalities, but restricted from accessing customer, order information, and other sensitive areas.
Default User (B2B)	Has view-only access to company profile and credit information, and full access to activities related to sales and quotes.	Full access to sales and quotes activities; view-only for company profile and credit information.
Senior Buyer (B2B)	Engaged in purchasing, with access to all Sales and Quotes resources, and view-only permissions to the Company Profile, User and Teams, Payment Information, and Company Credit.	Comprehensive access to Sales and Quotes, with limited viewing rights for company’s financial and profile data.
Assistant Buyer (B2B)	Assists in purchasing activities, with permissions to place orders using Checkout with Quote, and to view orders, quotes, and company profile information.	Permission to execute orders and access relevant purchasing data; view-only access to company profile information.

Additional Features


SSL Certificate	✓	X
Custom Domain	✓	✓
Free Custom Domain Included	X	X
International Domains	✓	✓
Mobile Responsive	✓	✓
Page Speed	X	✓
Website Builder Mobile App	X	X
Convert a Website To An App	✓	X
Website Analytics	✓	✓
Multilingual Sites	✓	✓
Multiple Users	✓	X

User Feedback

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

501 reviews

4.0 out of 5 stars

Carbonmade

27 reviews

4.2 out of 5 stars

Adobe Commerce (formerly Magento Commerce) receives high praise for its comprehensive ecommerce solutions, offering features like customer and order management, scalability, and customization options. Users appreciate its flexibility and ease of use, although some mention a learning curve due to its extensive features. Despite occasional drawbacks like slow speed or complexity, Adobe Commerce proves beneficial for businesses seeking robust ecommerce platforms, aiding in sales growth, customer management, and overall efficiency in managing online stores.

Users appreciate Carbonmade for its ease of use, modern design templates, and no-code platform, which simplifies creating professional portfolios. However, some express a desire for a freemium plan and note limitations in customization and mobile site loading times. The platform is highly recommended for creatives, particularly illustrators and graphic designers, for its variety of design options and efficient customer service. Despite concerns over pricing, the overall sentiment is positive, with users finding value in Carbonmade’s ability to showcase their work effectively and streamline portfolio management.

The making of this blog

We followed a clear, step-by-step process to write and research this article.

Our Ranking Criteria

FAQ

What are the main differences between Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) and Carbonmade?

Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) is designed for large-scale ecommerce operations with extensive customization capabilities and robust security features. It’s ideal for businesses that need a scalable and secure online store. Carbonmade, on the other hand, is tailored for creatives looking to showcase their work through simple, customizable layouts without ecommerce functionalities.

Which platform is better for ecommerce?

Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) is the superior choice for ecommerce. It offers comprehensive tools for managing large product inventories, complex payment processing, and multi-channel sales strategies. Carbonmade does not support ecommerce functionalities, making it unsuitable for online sales.

Can I use Carbonmade for business websites?

Carbonmade is primarily designed for creatives to showcase portfolios and is not well-suited for complex business websites. Adobe Commerce (ex Magento), with its extensive customization and integration capabilities, is better suited for creating detailed business or informational sites.

How do the platforms compare in terms of ease of use?

Carbonmade scores higher in ease of use, offering a user-friendly interface that is ideal for individuals without technical skills. Adobe Commerce (ex Magento), while powerful, has a steeper learning curve due to its extensive features and customization options.

What kind of support can I expect from each platform?

Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) provides comprehensive customer support including 24/7 access, a detailed knowledge base, and community forums. Carbonmade offers basic support through a ticket system and a help center, which may not cater to urgent support needs as effectively as Adobe Commerce.