Drupal vs Adobe Commerce(ex Magento): Comprehensive comparison guide for 2024

Final verdict

Drupal and Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) both offer powerful platforms, but they cater to different needs and user bases.

• 
  Drupal (Overall Grade: 6.4/10)
  
  is a highly flexible and extensible open-source CMS, ideal for developers and businesses looking to create complex websites with custom functionalities. It excels in design flexibility and user management, making it suitable for a variety of websites, from personal blogs to large corporate sites. However, its steep learning curve and the need for extensive customization can be challenging for beginners. When comparing Drupal vs Adobe Commerce (ex Magento), Drupal is a versatile choice for those who prioritize creative control and customization.
• 
  Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) (Overall Grade: 6.9/10)
  
  stands out for its robust ecommerce capabilities, advanced marketing tools, and strong security features. It’s the go-to platform for businesses aiming to scale their online stores with comprehensive ecommerce solutions. With AI-driven personalization, extensive integrations, and a user-friendly website editor, Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) is ideal for users seeking a powerful, growth-oriented ecommerce platform. Considering Drupal vs Adobe Commerce (ex Magento), Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) offers a more specialized and scalable solution for ecommerce businesses.

	Overall grade: 6.4	Overall grade: 6.9
Design functionalities & templates	7.8	6.7
Ease of use	5.4	5.4
Ecommerce	7.5	9.4
Website editors	7.5	7.8
Product testing options	7.1	3.9
Price	5.7	5.8
Hosting quality	0	8.1
Website speed optimization	6.4	6.6
Plugins/extensions and integrations	8.6	9.1
Marketing features	8.0	8.1
Customer support	6.7	8.3
Website security	8.3	8.4
AI capabilities	7.5	7.7
User management	9.1	8.0

Best for ecommerce

7.5

9.4

Verdict

: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) is the superior choice for ecommerce, offering a comprehensive set of tools and features that cater to both B2B and B2C businesses. Drupal, while flexible and extensible, may require more customization and has a steeper learning curve.

• 
  Drupal
  
  : Drupal, with its Drupal Commerce module, provides a flexible ecommerce solution integrated into its CMS. It offers features like product management, shopping cart, and payment gateway integration. However, it may require extensive customization and optimization for large-scale stores. Its flexibility makes it suitable for complex ecommerce needs, but it might be challenging for users unfamiliar with Drupal.
• 
  Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)
  
  : Adobe Commerce is an enterprise-level ecommerce platform with robust features such as product and inventory management, efficient order processing, and targeted marketing capabilities. It supports multiple brands and markets, offers AI-driven personalization, and ensures scalability with cloud-native solutions. Its comprehensive toolset and seamless integration with third-party applications make it ideal for businesses looking to establish and manage successful online stores.

Best for informational & business websites

7.5

7.4

• 
  Drupal
  
  : Drupal is a highly flexible and powerful content management system, making it an excellent choice for informational and business websites. Its vast array of modules and themes allows for extensive customization, catering to a wide range of website needs. Drupal’s open-source nature and strong community support make it a versatile and reliable option for developers looking to create complex websites with custom functionalities. With a score of 7.5, Drupal is well-suited for various types of websites, from personal blogs to corporate and government sites.
• 
  Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)
  
  : Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) is a versatile commerce platform that also supports informational and business websites. It offers AI-driven personalization, multiple brand support, and a range of developer tools for customization. While it excels in ecommerce functionalities, Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) can also be used for creating and managing informational websites. However, its primary focus on ecommerce may make it less ideal for purely informational sites. With a score of 7.4, Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) is a strong contender but may be better suited for businesses that require robust ecommerce capabilities alongside their informational content.

Detailed comparison

7.8

6.7

🏆

Winner: Drupal.

If you’re looking for a platform that offers more creative control and a wide array of design features, Drupal is the preferred choice.

Drupal, as a highly flexible and powerful content management system, offers a vast array of templates and designs to cater to virtually any website need. With thousands of themes available, users can choose from minimalist designs, industry-specific layouts, and highly customizable multipurpose themes.

Drupal Themes

Compared to Drupal, Adobe Commerce, formerly Magento, prioritizes flexibility over pre-built templates. While it offers a limited selection of base themes, users can access third-party themes for customization. Theme options are highly adaptable, allowing changes to layouts, colors, fonts, and the creation of custom page layouts.

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) Themes

Get a head start on website creation with AI

Create a custom website tailored to your business needs 10X faster with 10Web AI Website Builder!

Generate Your Website

No credit card required

5.4

5.4

🏆 Winner: Tie

. Both Drupal and Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) scored 5.4 in ease of use. These platforms are known for their flexibility and extensibility, making them powerful tools for building complex websites and applications. However, this flexibility comes with a steep learning curve, especially for beginners or those not familiar with web development principles. If you’re a beginner, you might find these platforms less intuitive than more user-friendly platforms.

Learning Resources

Both Drupal and Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) offer a wealth of learning resources, including extensive official documentation, vibrant community forums, and a variety of online courses and tutorials. The quality of these resources ranges from good to excellent, making these platforms accessible for beginners and beneficial for advanced users looking to deepen their expertise.

7.5

9.4

Drupal, with its Drupal Commerce module, offers a flexible ecommerce solution that can be integrated seamlessly into its content management system. It provides a wide array of features including product management, shopping cart, payment gateway integration, and customizable workflows that cater to complex pricing models and product variations. However, some of its downsides include a steep learning curve for users not familiar with Drupal, the potential need for extensive customization to meet specific ecommerce needs, and performance can be a concern for very large-scale stores without proper optimization.

Adobe Commerce, formerly known as Magento, is an enterprise-level ecommerce platform offering features such as product and inventory management, efficient order processing, customer account management, targeted marketing capabilities, diverse payment processing options, robust security measures, and scalability to accommodate business growth. With its comprehensive set of tools, Adobe Commerce is designed to assist businesses in establishing and managing successful online stores of varying sizes.

Ecommerce themes and templates	7.8	7.5
Product page customization	8.3	9.0
Payment processing and commissions	7.5	7.8
POS capabilities	5.5	7.0
Payment gateways	7.7	8.5
Product numbers	7.0	7.5
Additional ecommerce features	8.0	8.0

Drupal ecommerce features:

• Shopping Cart and Checkout Process
• Payment Gateway Integration
• Order Management and Invoicing
• Tax Calculation and VAT Support
• Shipping and Fulfillment
• Promotions and Discounts
• Reporting and Analytics
• Security and Compliance

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) ecommerce features:

• Product and Inventory Management
• Order Management
• Customer Management
• Marketing and Promotions
• Payment Processing
• Multi-Channel Commerce

Ecommerce themes & templates

Drupal offers a wide array of eCommerce themes designed to cater to different types of online stores, from clean and simple designs to more sophisticated and feature-rich options. These themes are built with responsiveness in mind, ensuring that stores function seamlessly across various devices. Themes like Fiora, DrupalMag, and Storefront highlight the diversity available, offering customization options to match the unique needs of each business. The availability and functionality of these themes underscore Drupal’s flexibility and power as an eCommerce platform.

Adobe Commerce, powered by Magento, offers a comprehensive ecosystem for ecommerce themes and templates, enabling businesses to customize their online stores to meet specific branding and functionality requirements. Themes in Adobe Commerce serve as the visual and structural framework for online stores, incorporating layout files, template files, translation files, and skins to define the look and feel.

Product page customization

Drupal offers extensive customization possibilities for product pages through its modular architecture, allowing for detailed content types, flexible displays with Views, and theme customizations. The Drupal Commerce module enriches e-commerce functionalities, enabling tailored product management, checkout flows, and payment systems. With the ability to develop custom modules, Drupal provides range of possibilities to meet specific e-commerce needs.

Adobe Commerce, formerly known as Magento, offers extensive customization options for product pages, enabling businesses to enhance the user experience and tailor product displays to their specific needs. This includes customizing layouts, product attributes, images and media, dynamic content like related products and reviews, and custom product options such as configurable and bundled products. These customizations can help businesses create a unique and user-friendly online shopping experience.

Payment processing

Drupal supports a wide range of payment gateways through third-party modules, including popular ones like PayPal, Stripe, and Authorize.Net. These modules enable seamless integration for e-commerce functionalities on Drupal sites. While Drupal itself does not charge any commissions or transaction fees, the individual payment gateways integrated with it do have their own fee structures, which typically include per-transaction charges and may also have monthly fees. The specific fees depend on the chosen payment gateway and the terms of service agreed upon by the website owner.

Adobe Commerce offers integrated payment solutions and commission management for seamless online transactions, alongside POS integration for omnichannel retail experiences. It supports a wide array of payment gateways, ensuring flexible and secure payment options for customers. These features make Adobe Commerce a versatile platform for businesses aiming to provide a comprehensive and secure shopping experience both online and in physical stores.

7.5

7.8

🏆

Winner: Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

. Adobe Commerce(ex Magento), with a score of 7.8, offers a user-friendly website editor with its Page Builder tool, designed for ease of use through drag-and-drop capabilities, allowing for simple management and customization of eCommerce sites without extensive developer involvement. It provides a flexible and intuitive platform for users to effortlessly design, update, and maintain their online stores, supported by a variety of design options and themes for tailored branding and promotional activities.

Drupal’s editor, scoring 7.5, offers a wide range of features tailored for content creation and management. It supports rich text editing, enabling users to format text, insert links, images, and media, as well as create tables and lists with ease. The editor is highly customizable, allowing administrators to configure toolbars and options according to the needs of their site. However, it can pose challenges for beginners due to its wide range of features and customization options. Learning to navigate its interface and utilize its full capabilities often requires time and effort.

Mobile editor/app

0

0

🏆

Winner: None

. Neither Drupal nor Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) offer mobile apps for managing your website, which means that any changes to your website will need to be made through a desktop interface. This may not be a significant issue for some users, but it does limit the ability to make quick changes or updates on the go.

Drupal, on the one hand, does not provide a dedicated mobile editor or app for website editing. This means that users will need to rely on the desktop interface for all website management tasks, including content editing, design changes, layout adjustments, and more.

Adobe Commerce (ex Magento), on the other hand, also lacks a mobile app or editor for website management. Like Drupal, users will need to use the desktop interface for all website editing tasks.

In summary, neither Drupal nor Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) offer the convenience of mobile website editing, which may be a drawback for users who need to make quick changes or updates on the go.

7.1

3.9

Overall Result

:

Drupal Wins

. Drupal scores 7.1 in product testing options, while Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) scores 3.9. Drupal, being an open-source CMS, is free to use and does not require a trial period. However, it does not offer the possibility to test premium features. On the other hand, Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) does not offer a free or trial version, but it is possible to test premium features by requesting a demo version for a trial period. Neither platform offers a money back guarantee.

Free Plan	Yes (open-source software)	No
Trial Duration	No	No
Testing Premium Features	No	Yes, by requesting a demo version
Money Back Guarantee	No	No

5.7

5.8

Drupal is a free open-source CMS, but users need to purchase a domain, web hosting, and website builder subscriptions separately. Adobe Commerce, on the other hand, is a premium service with prices starting from approximately $2,000. It is designed to deliver scalable, secure, and extensive eCommerce solutions tailored to a wide range of business demands.

	Offerings	Offerings
$0+	No offering at this amount.	Adobe Commerce Pro and Managed Services ($2000/month): Adobe Commerce Pro and Managed Services are designed to deliver scalable, secure, and extensive eCommerce solutions tailored to a wide range of business demands. It offers a comprehensive set of ecommerce tools, including product and inventory management, efficient order processing, customer account management, targeted marketing capabilities, diverse payment processing options, robust security measures, and scalability to accommodate business growth. It also offers both self-hosted and cloud-hosted options, providing flexibility and optimized performance. While it does not have an AI website builder, it offers a powerful theme framework for comprehensive control, including frontend editing for basic adjustments. Experienced developers can employ custom code for unique designs and advanced functionalities.

0

8.1

🏆

Winner: Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) offers robust and scalable eCommerce solutions with both self-hosted and cloud-hosted options, providing flexibility and optimized performance. On the other hand, Drupal does not offer hosting services directly, so users need to rely on third-party hosting providers.

Do they offer hosting?	No	Yes
Type of hosting:	Depends on hosting provider	Self Hosting, Managed Hosting
Uptime:	Depends on hosting provider	Uptime Guarantee for Adobe Managed hosting is provided
Data Centers:	Depends on hosting provider	Adobe Commerce on Cloud infrastructure Leverages Amazon Web Services (AWS), Specific data center details not publicly available

6.4

6.6

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)

Both Drupal and Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) offer various strategies for website speed optimization. However, Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) slightly outperforms Drupal in this aspect.

Focus	User-guided optimization	CDN, Database optimization, Caching, Indexing
Performance Tools	User-guided tools	Built-in tools
Key Strategies	User-guided optimization	CDN, Database optimization, Caching, Indexing
Load Times	Varies depending on optimization and website complexity	Varies widely, dependent on optimization
Page Speed Scores Range	Varies depending on optimization and website complexity	Scores vary; influenced by plugins, images
Core Web Vitals Improvement	Depends on users	Emphasis on LCP, FID, CLS improvements

Drupal, an open-source content management system (CMS), allows users to optimize almost all aspects of their website. However, the load times and PageSpeed scores vary depending on the optimization and website complexity. The Core Web Vitals improvements also depend on the users.

On the other hand, Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) offers strategies for speed optimization such as CDN, Database optimization, Caching, and Indexing. The load times and PageSpeed scores also vary widely, depending on the optimization. However, Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) places an emphasis on LCP, FID, CLS improvements for Core Web Vitals.

Get a head start on website creation with AI

Create a custom website tailored to your business needs 10X faster with 10Web AI Website Builder!

Generate Your Website

No credit card required

8.6

9.1

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce(ex Magento).

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) scores 9.1, outperforming Drupal’s 8.6. Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) offers a vast array of extensions and plugins, estimated to be in the tens of thousands, covering aspects such as marketing, payment processing, shipping, content management, security, and optimization. On the other hand, Drupal also offers a vast array of over 51,000 plugins, but Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)’s extensive range of plugins and seamless integrations give it the upper hand.

It is worth mentioning that most of Drupal’s modules are freely available and open source, embodying Drupal’s commitment to accessible and communal software development. On the other hand, Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)’s plugins range from free options with limited features to paid subscriptions or one-time fees, with the possibility of custom development costing more for unique requirements.

Drupal Applications

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) Applications

8.0

8.1

🏆

Overall Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)

. Adobe Commerce (ex Magento) edges out Drupal with its more advanced and integrated marketing tools, especially for ads and promotions. However, Drupal’s flexibility and extensibility make it a strong contender, especially when third-party modules are utilized.

SEO Tools	Yes, with SEO modules such as Yoast SEO	Yes
Email Marketing	Yes, but with third-party extensions, such as MailChimp	Yes
Blogging	Yes	Can be integrated with platforms like WordPress
Social Media Integration	Yes	Yes
Analytics and Reporting	Yes, basic built-in features, and Google Analytics integrations through modules	Adobe Commerce integrates with Google Analytics and other analytics tools
Ads and Promotions	Yes, but with third-party extensions	Advanced marketing tools for creating and managing promotions, coupons, and personalized content

6.7

8.3

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

. When comparing Drupal vs Adobe Commerce(ex Magento), Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) takes the lead with its robust 24/7 customer support through phone, email, and live chat. The platform also offers a comprehensive knowledge base, community forums, and extensive documentation, ensuring users have access to a wide range of support resources. Additionally, Adobe Commerce provides enterprise-level support with dedicated account management and access to a global network of experts, making it a strong choice for businesses seeking reliable and extensive support.

Drupal, on the other hand, offers a community support system through Drupal.org, including forums and documentation. Professional 24/7 support services are available via providers like Drupal Connect, with flexible “pay-as-you-go” plans. While Drupal’s community and professional support options are valuable, they may not be as comprehensive or readily accessible as Adobe Commerce’s offerings, particularly for enterprise-level needs.

8.3

8.4

🏆

Winner: Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

. Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) edges out Drupal with a slightly higher security score. Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) provides secure private data storage and protection through advanced encryption and access control measures. It also offers regular security updates and patches to address vulnerabilities, secure payment processing, and tools for monitoring suspicious activity on the website.

Drupal, on the other hand, also emphasizes website security through regular updates, robust configuration options, and built-in mechanisms for preventing common web vulnerabilities. It supports advanced security features like two-factor authentication and provides extensive access control capabilities. However, it falls slightly short in comparison to Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) in terms of the overall security score.

7.5

7.7

AI Website Builder
AI Ecommerce Features	Chatbots, content creation, marketing automation, cognitive services	Personalized product recommendations, visual search, inventory management, price optimization
AI Content Generation	AI Connect module for content generation and SEO optimization	Automated generation of product descriptions and SEO optimization
Additional AI Features	AI-based search enhancements, content personalization, automated content moderation	AI-powered chatbots, security enhancements, marketing automation

🏆 Winner: Adobe Commerce (ex Magento)

. Adobe Commerce, with a score of 7.7, integrates AI across various aspects of eCommerce, enhancing customer service, security, and marketing. It automates the generation of unique and compelling product descriptions, saving time and ensuring consistency across large inventories. Additionally, AI-driven tools assist in SEO optimization by analyzing keywords, trends, and competitor content, suggesting or generating improvements to enhance search engine rankings and drive organic traffic.

Drupal, with a score of 7.5, enhances content creation through AI with modules like AI Connect, enabling integration with AI services for diverse functionalities like content generation, SEO optimization, and multilingual support. The platform also integrates OpenAI and ChatGPT, offering features for text completions, editorial advice, and image generation using text descriptions. However, it does not provide a screenshot of an AI feature.

9.1

8.0

🏆 Winner: Drupal

. Drupal’s flexible permission and role system allows for an unlimited number of users to manage and edit a website, only constrained by server capacity and practical management considerations. Administrators can create various roles, such as “Editor” or “Administrator”, each with customized permissions. There’s no inherent limit in Drupal on the number of users with administrative or editing capabilities, enabling extensive collaboration and content management possibilities.

On the other hand, the number of users who can edit an Adobe Commerce website depends on user licenses and roles. User licenses, bought separately, determine the total number of users allowed, with additional licenses purchasable as needed. Roles and permissions, managed within the available licenses, control access and modifications, ensuring data security and efficient workflow.

Drupal User Roles and Access Levels:

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento) User Roles and Access Levels:

Additional Features

SSL Certificate
Custom Domain
Free Custom Domain Included
International Domains
Mobile Responsive
Page Speed
Website Builder Mobile App
Convert a Website To An App
Website Analytics
Multilingual Sites
Multiple Users

User Feedback

Drupal

415 reviews

3.8 out of 5 stars

Adobe Commerce(ex Magento)

501 reviews

4.0 out of 5 stars

Users appreciate Drupal for its ease of use, security, and flexibility as an open-source CMS, highlighting its ability to scale and support a variety of websites and applications with modern technology tools. The community and documentation are frequently mentioned positives, providing ample support and resources. However, criticisms include a relative lack of plugins and themes compared to competitors like WordPress, the learning curve for customization without coding, and some challenges with installation and updates. The platform is praised for its robust content management capabilities, enabling users to manage content and user access efficiently. Overall, feedback underscores Drupal’s strength in creating secure, customizable, and scalable web solutions, despite some desires for more intuitive UI and easier setup.

Adobe Commerce (formerly Magento Commerce) receives high praise for its comprehensive ecommerce solutions, offering features like customer and order management, scalability, and customization options. Users appreciate its flexibility and ease of use, although some mention a learning curve due to its extensive features. Despite occasional drawbacks like slow speed or complexity, Adobe Commerce proves beneficial for businesses seeking robust ecommerce platforms, aiding in sales growth, customer management, and overall efficiency in managing online stores.

FAQ

Build your website in 1 minute

Build your website in 1 minute

Tired of comparing? Try 10Web AI Website Builder and create your website in one minute.

See How It Works