Carrd vs Instapage: Comprehensive comparison guide for 2024

Final verdict

Carrd and Instapage both offer unique advantages, catering to different user needs and preferences.

• 
  Carrd (Overall Grade: 6.1/10)
  
  is ideal for individuals and small businesses looking to create simple, single-page websites quickly and affordably. Its user-friendly interface, variety of templates, and ease of use make it a great choice for beginners. However, it lacks advanced ecommerce and AI capabilities, making it less suitable for complex projects.
• 
  Instapage (Overall Grade: 6.6/10)
  
  excels in creating high-converting landing pages with its comprehensive suite of marketing tools, AI content generation, and extensive integrations. It is perfect for businesses focused on optimizing their advertising conversions and marketing campaigns. While it is more expensive, its advanced features and robust support make it a valuable investment for serious marketers.

Best for ecommerce

Verdict

: Carrd and Instapage are not primarily designed for ecommerce, but they offer some features that can be used for this purpose. Carrd is suitable for basic product listings and payment integrations, while Instapage provides more advanced integration options with platforms like Shopify.

• 
  Carrd
  
  : Carrd allows for basic product listing and payment integration with PayPal and Stripe. It offers a selection of 14 ecommerce templates aimed at users looking to quickly launch online stores. These templates are crafted with a focus on simplicity and conversion optimization. However, Carrd’s ecommerce capabilities are limited, making it more suitable for small-scale operations or individuals looking to sell a few products online.
• 
  Instapage
  
  : Instapage supports integration with ecommerce platforms like Shopify and payment gateways such as Stripe and PayPal. While it does not have ecommerce-specific templates, its focus on creating high-converting landing pages can be beneficial for driving sales. Instapage’s advanced marketing tools and analytics make it a better choice for businesses looking to optimize their advertising and conversion rates. However, its ecommerce functionalities are still limited compared to dedicated ecommerce platforms.

Best for informational & business websites

Verdict

: When it comes to creating informational business websites, both Carrd and Instapage offer unique advantages. Carrd is ideal for those seeking simplicity and affordability, while Instapage excels in providing advanced features and integrations for marketing-focused landing pages.

• 
  Carrd
  
  : Carrd is a straightforward platform designed for building fully responsive, single-page websites. Its ease of use and variety of templates make it a great choice for individuals and small businesses looking to establish an online presence quickly and efficiently. With a score of 7.9, Carrd is particularly suitable for users who prioritize simplicity and cost-effectiveness.
• 
  Instapage
  
  : Instapage, also scoring 7.9, is a comprehensive landing page platform that focuses on improving advertising conversion through personalization and optimization. It offers a range of tools for creating, testing, and optimizing landing pages, making it ideal for businesses that need to execute marketing campaigns efficiently. Instapage’s advanced features and integrations make it a powerful choice for those looking to enhance their marketing efforts.

Detailed comparison

🏆

Winner: Instapage.

If you’re looking for a platform that offers more creative control and a wide array of design features, Instapage is the preferred choice.

Carrd is a versatile platform that offers a wide variety of templates and designs, catering to different needs and preferences. Users can choose from a broad selection of themes, ranging from simple and minimalist to complex and dynamic layouts, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The platform continuously updates its library with new designs, keeping up with the latest trends in web design. With its user-friendly interface, Carrd makes it easy for users to customize templates, allowing for a high degree of personalization and creativity in creating unique websites.

Carrd Themes

Compared to Carrd, Instapage provides an extensive collection of 100+ design templates for website building, business-specific templates. These templates are tailored to support small teams and businesses in executing their marketing campaigns efficiently, including features for marketing automation, CRM, and analytics integrations.

Instapage Themes

🏆 Winner: Carrd

. Scoring a solid 9.0, Carrd stands out for its simplicity and ease of use, making it ideal for beginners and those seeking to create single-page websites quickly. Instapage, with a score of 8.5, offers an intuitive drag-and-drop interface that simplifies the creation of landing pages, but it has a slightly lower ease of use score. If ease of use is a priority, Carrd is the clear winner in this category.

Learning Resources

🏆 Winner: Instapage

. While both platforms offer quality learning resources, Instapage offers a comprehensive set of learning resources, including blogs, webinars, videos, podcasts, ebooks, dictionaries, guides, and customer stories, making it easier for users to learn and adapt.

Carrd and Instapage are not primarily designed for ecommerce, but they offer some features that can be used for this purpose. Carrd allows for basic product listing and payment integration with PayPal and Stripe, while Instapage supports integration with ecommerce platforms like Shopify.

Carrd ecommerce features:

• Paypal and Stripe Integration
• External Widgets integrations
• Basic Product Listing options

Instapage ecommerce features:

• Shopify integration
• Payment gateways such as Stripe and Paypal

Ecommerce themes & templates

Carrd provides a selection of 14 e-commerce templates aimed at users looking to quickly launch online stores for products ranging from e-books to physical goods. These templates are crafted with a focus on simplicity and conversion optimization, featuring designs that vary from dark themes to minimalist aesthetics. They are priced starting at $19 or $25, depending on the template, and require a Pro Standard account or higher due to the use of advanced elements and widgets. On the other hand, Instapage does not have ecommerce specific templates.

Product page customization

Carrd offers a streamlined approach to ecommerce product page customization, primarily through integrations with third-party platforms such as Stripe, Lemon Squeezy, and Gumroad. Users can create product pages within Carrd by adding product details like name, description, image, and price, and then integrate a checkout button using Carrd’s Widget element for platforms like Stripe. Users can integrate third-party services for ecommerce functionalities, but the customization possibilities for product pages would then depend on the capabilities of those external platforms. Instapage does not have product page customization capabilities.

Payment processing

When it comes to payment processing, Carrd allows for payment-enabled forms for Pro Plus users or higher, integrating with Stripe Checkout for payment processing. This setup enables creating forms for various transactions like order forms or paid email lists. The process requires setting up the payment through Stripe, either via a preconfigured price or a custom price, and entering Stripe API keys. There’s no direct mention of Carrd charging commissions or offering POS capabilities within this documentation. For payment gateways, it specifically supports Stripe and Paypal. Instapage supports payment gateway integration, notably through external systems and third-party services like Commence Payments for Stripe, facilitating various payment options such as Apple Pay, Google Pay, and card payments. The platform itself does not directly charge commissions for transactions, but payment gateways may have their own fees. While Instapage specializes in creating high-converting landing pages with a focus on online marketing, it does not explicitly offer Point of Sale (POS) capabilities, suggesting a primary use case away from direct sales or retail transactions.

🏆

Winner: Instapage

. With a score of 7.5, Instapage offers a comprehensive website builder focused on creating and optimizing landing pages for various marketing campaigns. It provides a drag-and-drop editor, AI content generation, detailed analytics, and extensive customization through custom code editing, alongside security and compliance features. The platform supports collaboration, integrates with numerous marketing tools, and is designed to streamline the process of building, testing, and optimizing landing pages to increase conversions.

Carrd, scoring 7.0, offers a website builder editor designed for simplicity and efficiency, catering primarily to users looking to create single-page websites. It provides a user-friendly interface that allows for easy drag-and-drop functionality, enabling users to add, customize, and position elements such as text, images, buttons, and forms with minimal effort. The editor also provides a range of pre-designed templates and responsive design options, ensuring that websites look professional and work seamlessly across various devices.

Mobile editor/app

🏆

Winner: Carrd

. Both Carrd and Instapage do not offer a dedicated mobile editor app. However, Carrd allows users to edit their websites on a mobile browser, giving it a slight edge over Instapage in terms of mobile editing. This feature can be particularly useful for users who need to make quick changes on the go. However, it’s important to note that both platforms are primarily designed for desktop use, and their full range of features and capabilities are best utilized on a desktop interface.

Overall Result

:

Instapage wins

. Instapage scores slightly higher than Carrd with a score of 6.1 compared to Carrd’s 6.0. Both platforms offer a free trial period, with Instapage offering a longer duration of 14 days compared to Carrd’s 7 days. However, it’s important to note that Instapage requires users to fill in their payment information for the trial, and users may be charged automatically if they don’t cancel by the end of the trial period. Both platforms allow testing of premium features during the trial period. Instapage offers a 24-hour money-back guarantee, while Carrd does not offer a money-back guarantee.

Carrd offers more affordable pricing plans, making it a great choice for individuals and small businesses. Instapage, while more expensive, provides a comprehensive landing page platform with advanced features, especially for businesses looking to maximize their conversion potential.

🏆

Winner: Instapage

Instapage offers cloud hosting with a 99.9% uptime guarantee, which gives it an edge over Carrd. Carrd offers shared hosting but does not provide specific information on bandwidth or storage limitations, and it does not have an uptime guarantee. Both platforms do not disclose information about their data centers.

🏆 Winner: Carrd

Both Carrd and Instapage prioritize website performance and page speed, but Carrd has a higher website speed optimization score and uses more effective strategies for speed optimization.

Carrd, a simple yet powerful platform for building fully responsive, single-page websites, has a higher website speed optimization score than Instapage. Carrd’s strategies for speed optimization include mobile responsive design, caching, and Cloudflare CDN. Given that websites built with Carrd are fairly simple, load times are expected to be minimal, and page speed scores are expected to be high. However, Carrd does not disclose any information related to Core Web Vital improvements.

Instapage, a comprehensive landing page platform designed to improve advertising conversion, uses strategies like responsive design, image optimization, and caching for speed optimization. Load times and PageSpeed scores vary depending on optimization. Like Carrd, Instapage does not provide any information on their Core Web Vital improvements.

🏆 Winner: Instapage.

With a score of 6.8, Instapage offers over 40 integrations with third-party platforms, including major CRM, email marketing, analytics, and advertising tools. This allows users to connect their landing pages seamlessly with essential digital marketing tools and services, enhancing the overall marketing funnel.

On the other hand, Carrd, with a score of 5.8, offers a range of plugins and extensions, including both free and paid options. However, some plugins require at least the Pro Standard plan, while others necessitate the Pro Plus plan.

In terms of what can be extended, Carrd plugins enable functionalities beyond its base features, including advanced user interactions and sophisticated content presentation. Instapage, on the other hand, allows for advanced analytics, sophisticated A/B testing, and direct email marketing automation, among other enhancements through its integrations.

When it comes to the top integrations, Carrd relies mostly on third-party platforms such as Elfsight, while Instapage supports a comprehensive range of integrations across various categories, including CRM, e-commerce, and analytics.

Instapage Applications

🏆

Overall Winner: Instapage

. Instapage stands out for its comprehensive suite of marketing tools, especially in analytics and ad campaign management. Carrd, while offering a simpler and more straightforward approach, allows for third-party integrations for email marketing and ads and promotions.

🏆 Winner: Instapage

. Comparing Carrd vs Instapage, Instapage takes the lead in this category with its comprehensive support options. Instapage offers live chat support available 24 hours a day from Monday to Friday, along with email and toll-free phone support during business hours. This ensures users have multiple channels to seek help and maintain a written record of their service requests. Additionally, Instapage provides personalized assistance for enterprise users through Success Managers and Launch Specialists, enhancing the overall support experience.

Carrd, on the other hand, provides 24/7 email support with a typical response time within 24 hours. While this is beneficial for users who prefer written communication, it lacks the immediacy and variety of support channels that Instapage offers. Carrd does not provide enterprise-level support, which may be a limitation for larger businesses seeking more tailored assistance.

🏆

Winner: Instapage

. Instapage’s commitment to security is evident in its compliance with SOC 2 Type I and Type II, GDPR, and CCPA regulations. It employs a comprehensive Information Security Program based on ISO 27001/2 and NIST 800-53 frameworks, covering multiple aspects of security from asset management to incident response. All landing pages support SSL/HTTPS to ensure secure client data handling and privacy.

Carrd also prioritizes security by automatically enabling SSL for all sites published on .carrd.co URLs, extending to custom domains and subdomains. However, it does not provide as much detail about its data storage and protection practices as Instapage, resulting in a slightly lower security score.

🏆 Winner: Instapage

. Instapage, with a score of 6.0, utilizes AI to enhance the landing page creation and optimization process. Its AI features focus on content generation and dynamic traffic allocation to better performing test variants.

Carrd, with a score of 0.0, does not have any AI capabilities. It is a simple and straightforward platform for building single-page websites, focusing on ease of use and customization options.

🏆 Winner: Instapage

. Both Carrd and Instapage offer different approaches to user management.

• Carrd is primarily designed for individual use or small teams, with each account managing its own sites. The platform introduced a Team feature to allow multiple users to collaborate, but traditionally, Carrd sites are managed by a single account holder with full control. The specifics of access levels and permissions for collaborators, if available, are less detailed but generally include editing capabilities.
• On Instapage, users managing a website can be assigned different roles: Viewer, Editor, or Manager. A Viewer has limited access, only able to view pages. An Editor can edit pages, and a Manager has full access except for billing information and the audit log. The number of users you can invite depends on your subscription limits. However, only one user can edit a page at a time to prevent overwrite issues.

Instapage User Roles and Access Levels:

Additional Features

User Feedback

Users overwhelmingly praise Carrd for its user-friendly interface, excellent customer support, and attractive templates, making website creation effortless and enjoyable. The drag-and-drop builder, affordability, and mobile-friendly designs are highlighted as significant benefits. However, some users express limitations, such as the inability to create multi-page websites or a desire for more design options. Overall, Carrd is praised for its affordability, ease of use, and suitability for creating quick, simple webpages.

Instapage users generally appreciate its user-friendly interface, robust customer support, and seamless integration capabilities, highlighting its effectiveness in creating high-quality, high-converting landing pages optimized for lead capture. Positive feedback emphasizes the platform’s ease of use, allowing both experienced marketers and newcomers to quickly design and deploy landing pages, along with its broad range of integrations with other marketing tools and CRM systems. However, some users encounter challenges with mobile responsiveness, custom domain settings, and occasional bugs.

FAQ