All in One SEO vs Yoast: The WordPress SEO Plugin Battle

When it comes to optimizing your website for search engines, having a reliable SEO plugin for your WordPress site is crucial. Two popular plugins in the market are All in One SEO and Yoast. In this article, we will compare the key features, functionality, and overall performance of All in One SEO and Yoast and will understand the strengths and weaknesses of each plugin to help you make an informed decision on which one suits your specific needs.

If you’re a WordPress user looking to optimize your website for search engines, chances are you’ve heard of the popular SEO plugins All in One SEO and Yoast. 

Both plugins offer a range of features to help you improve your website’s ranking on Google and other search engines but choosing one might be confusing. In this article, we’ll compare All in One SEO vs Yoast and help you decide which plugin can better fit the requirements of your website.

Ready to dive into the battle? 

Let’s get started!


Yoast SEO vs All In One SEO feature comparison battle

Both All in One SEO and Yoast SEO are highly popular WordPress plugins that offer a range of features to optimize your website for search engines. If you’re pressed for time, here’s a brief comparison between All in One SEO and Yoast. However, we highly recommend reading the full article for a more comprehensive analysis. Here’s a summary to help you get an overview.

Aspect/Feature All in One SEO Yoast SEO Winner
Pricing Offers affordable pricing and more features for the price Offers a free version with limited features and a more expensive premium version All in One SEO
Meta Tags Offers dynamic tags in title and description, supports Open Graph and Twitter Cards Offers similar meta tags features  Tie
Keyword and Content Analysis Provides more comprehensive and detailed suggestions for individual pages and posts Provides lesser detailed and optimized suggestions  All in One SEO
Technical SEO Offers a range of technical SEO features, including XML sitemap generation and robots.txt editing Offers similar technical SEO features but lesser-comprehensive All in One SEO
Link Management Offers a built-in link management tool Offers a similar link management tool but with limited functionalities All in One SEO
Tracking and Analytics Supports Google Analytics and offers basic tracking and analytics features with more control over your analytics data. Offers similar tracking and analytics features, but there are limited functionalities All in One SEO
Integrations Offers integrations with popular third-party services like WooCommerce and ACF Offers similar third-party integrations Tie

As you have seen the comparison table above, now let’s delve deeper into each feature of All in One SEO vs Yoast. In this section, we will analyze and compare the two plugins in various areas, providing you with valuable insights that can help you make an informed decision about which one is the best fit for your needs.


Pricing

Pricing is an important factor to consider when it comes to choosing the right SEO plugin for your WordPress website. Let’s take a closer look at the necessary details. 

Free version price

In the debate between Yoast vs All in One SEO, both plugins have free versions for beginners. All in One SEO’s free version suits hobby sites or small businesses. But for more advanced features, Yoast SEO’s paid versions may be a better fit, providing multiple focus keywords and other extras not found in All in One SEO’s paid packages.

Premium price

All in One SEO pricing structure comes in four paid plans: basic, plus, pro, and elite. The basic plan costs $49.60/year and is suitable for one website. The Plus plan costs $99.60/year and can be used on up to three sites. 

All in One SEO Pricing

The pro plan costs $199.60/year and is designed for up to ten sites, while the elite plan costs $299.60/year and can be used on up to 100 sites.

On the other hand, Yoast pricing also offers several options. Yoast SEO Premium offers two pricing plans. The Yoast SEO Premium plugin costs $99/year (ex. VAT), while the Plugin subscription costs $229/year (ex. VAT).

Yoast Pricing

When it comes to comparing Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO, the Premium plugin subscription for Yoast SEO offers a wide range of features such as helpful suggestions for content quality and links, previews for sharing on social media, and a lot more. 

Winner: All in One SEO

Meta tags

When it comes to choosing between All in One SEO Pack vs Yoast SEO, it’s important to look at their respective meta tag functionalities. Here’s a comparison of some of the key features they offer related to meta tags:

Title and meta description

All in One SEO offers automatic SEO generation, and dynamic SEO smart tags, which automatically generate keywords based on the page’s content or post. 

Title and Meta Description in All In One SEO

Additionally, All in One SEO allows users to manually customize the title and meta descriptions for each page or post.

But if we come back to our comparison of All in One SEO vs Yoast, Yoast offers title and meta description templating, which allows users to create a snippet appearance in the search results. 

Title and Meta Description in Yoast

Users can customize the title and description for each page or post, and Yoast SEO offers real-time previews of how the snippet will look in the search results.

Overall, in our battle of All in One SEO vs Yoast, it can be said that both plugins offer useful functionalities for optimizing titles and meta descriptions depending on their requirements but All in One SEO’s automatic SEO generation and dynamic smart tags shine out.

MetaData import and export

In terms of importing settings and metadata, All in One SEO stands out with its straightforward process.

MetaData Import and Export in All in One SEO

Yoast SEO offers similar functionality, Yoast bulk editor that lets you export and import your SEO data, including SEO titles, meta descriptions, and focused keyphrases. This feature is available in both the free and premium versions of the plugin.

MetaData Import and Export in Yoast

Auto-generation of meta tags

All in One SEO automatically generates meta descriptions for your content based on the Meta Description settings. This is helpful for those with limited time or resources. Yoast provides a more customizable approach to auto-generating meta tags and can be a great time-saver for those managing larger websites.

Auto-Generation of Meta Tags in Yoast

Social media tags / Open Graph

When it comes to optimizing your website for social media, both All in One SEO and Yoast have got you covered with their respective features. With All in One SEO’s Pack Pro WordPress SEO plugin, you can easily manage your All in One SEO Open Graph and Twitter Card metadata for social media shares.

Open Graph in All in One SEO

Similarly, Yoast Open Graph offers a preview feature for its Premium users, providing full control over how your posts look on Facebook and Twitter.

Open Graph in Yoast

Winner: It’s a Tie!

Keyword and content analysis

One of the most important aspects of on-page optimization is analyzing both keywords and content. In this section, we’ll be comparing the two popular tools that help with this task.

Multiple focus keywords analysis

All in One SEO Pro allows you to optimize your content for multiple keyphrases, which can help you rank higher in search engine results. 

Multiple Focus Keywords Analysis in All in One SEO

With this feature, you can easily add multiple keyphrases to your content and follow SEO best practices for each keyphrase. 

On the other hand, Yoast SEO‘s multiple focus keywords analysis feature is available only to premium users. This feature lets you optimize your content for multiple keyphrases, variations, synonyms, and more in order to reach a larger audience. 

Multiple Focus Keywords Analysis in Yoast

With Yoast SEO Premium, you can also check the optimization of each keyword, including the keyword density and placement, to improve your chances of ranking higher in search engine results.

Content analyzer

All in One SEO offers a premium Content Analyzer feature that helps you optimize your pages for unlimited SEO keywords. On the other hand, Yoast’s free version also includes a content analysis tool that analyzes your content for SEO factors. However, it does not provide recommendations for improving your content, which needs Yoast SEO Premium access.

Duplicate content detection

All in One SEO also has a feature that can help you detect duplicate content on your website. It scans your site for any duplicate content and flags it for you, making it easy to fix the issue and improve your SEO.

Yoast SEO, on the other hand, includes checks that tell you when you’re using a duplicate keyphrase and when your link texts are the same as your keyphrase. This helps prevent keyphrase cannibalization, which can negatively impact your SEO efforts.

Winner: All in One SEO

Both plugins make it convenient to analyze content, but, All in One SEO stands out as it offers a more actionable plan for optimization.  

Technical SEO

Technical SEO can seem like a daunting task, but it’s a vital component of any successful SEO strategy. Let’s now look at two popular technical SEO tools and discuss how they can help you optimize your website for search engines. 

XML sitemap

All in One SEO sitemap is easy to set up, which helps search engines discover and crawl your pages more efficiently. The sitemap is enabled by default and requires very little configuration. 

XML Sitemap in All in One SEO

Once set up, the sitemap is automatically updated whenever you publish or change content on your site, ensuring that search engines are always aware of the latest updates to your website.

On the other hand, Yoast SEO also provides an XML sitemap feature, which includes a Yoast sitemap index and individual sitemaps that are automatically updated as you add or remove content from your website.

XML Sitemap in Yoast

Diverse structured data/schema

All in One SEO Schema feature offers a comprehensive set of structured data tools that allow you to provide Google with properly formatted markup.

Diverse Structured Data in All in One SEO

With All in One SEO, you can easily set up schema markup for your website and ensure it is properly formatted to meet Google’s guidelines. This includes local SEO schema markup, which is essential if you want your business to appear in local searches and Google Maps.

On the other hand, Yoast SEO offers an automatic structured data feature that helps search engines understand the content on your pages, making it easier for them to display rich results in their search listings. 

Schema in Yoast

In addition, Yoast SEO’s Schema tab allows you to easily set the type of content you have on your pages, including articles, recipes, products, and more. Overall, both All in One SEO and Yoast offer powerful structured data tools that can help improve your website’s visibility in search results. It’s important to consider your specific needs and goals when deciding which plugin is right for you.

Robots.txt and .htaccess file editing

When it comes to managing the robots.txt and .htaccess files in WordPress, both plugins offer powerful tools to help you control your website’s search engine visibility. With All in One SEO robots.txt, you can easily manage the file that WordPress generates, giving you greater control over the instructions you give to web crawlers about your site.

Robots.txt file editing in All in One SEO

This feature allows you to exclude certain pages or directories from being indexed by search engines, or even prevent specific user agents from accessing your site altogether.

On the other hand, Yoast SEO provides an easy way to create or edit the Yoast robots.txt file directly from the WordPress dashboard. This allows you to quickly and easily update your website’s instructions for search engine crawlers without having to leave the WordPress admin area. 

Robots.txt file editor in Yoast

Yoast SEO also includes a feature that lets you preview your robots.txt file to ensure that it is working correctly. Overall, both plugins offer tools for editing the .htaccess file, which is another important file that controls how search engines interact with your site. These features allow you to customize your website’s settings even further, giving you greater control over your search engine optimization efforts.

Site audit

When it comes to site audit features, All in One SEO offers a comprehensive analysis of your website’s SEO in just a few seconds. It provides detailed explanations of any critical errors found, along with resources to help you fix them yourself. 

Site Audit in All in One SEO

With All in One SEO, you can also analyze your site speed and receive specific recommendations on how to improve it.

On the other hand, Yoast’s free tool, Yoast SEO analysis, provides a basic site audit. However, the real power of Yoast comes with its premium version, which includes an expanded and smarter SEO analysis. 

SEO Analysis in Yoast

One of the core features of Yoast SEO is its SEO analysis, which checks your content against SEO best practices and provides feedback in the form of green, orange, and red bullets. With Yoast SEO Premium, you have all the tools you need to improve the visibility of your content and boost your search engine rankings.

Winner: All in One SEO

Both plugins make it convenient to analyze content, but, All in One SEO stands out as it offers a more actionable plan for optimization.  

Link management

Properly managing your website’s links can help improve your search engine rankings and drive more traffic to your site. Let’s dive in and see how these two stack up against each other!

Internal link manager

All in One SEO comes with Link Assistant, which allows you to create better internal links on your WordPress website by crawling the links and providing a detailed report. 

Internal Link management in All in One SEO

With this, you can view the number of internal links, outbound links, and affiliate links for each post or page. 

The Yoast SEO plugin, on the other hand, comes with a basic internal linking tool accessible only to premium users. 

It also scans your content for Yoast internal linking and provides suggestions for improving them but it is not as comprehensive as the All in One SEO link assistant. 

Redirection manager

Both All in One SEO and Yoast SEO Premium have a redirection manager functionality that allows you to manage redirects on your WordPress site. All in One SEO’s free version includes 301 redirects, 404 error tracking, and the ability to redirect multiple URLs to the same destination URL, along with a complete log of all redirects and 404s on your site. 

Yoast SEO Premium also includes a built-in redirection manager that lets you redirect pages to another location on your site and automates the process for existing content. Yoast SEO redirect also lets you create a redirect when you change the URL of a post or page and notifies you to create a redirect when you delete one. Overall, both plugins offer similar features with slightly different approaches to managing and automating redirects.

Editable canonical URL

An editable canonical URL is a feature in SEO plugins that lets you specify the preferred URL for a page or post, which search engines should treat as the main or authoritative version, improving your site’s SEO. 

In All in One SEO, you can specify your own canonical URL by editing your content and scrolling down to the AIOSEO Settings section. It also lets you remove the page numbers from paginated content’s Canonical URLs. Editable Canonical URL in All in One SEO

With Yoast SEO, you get two ways to deal with canonical URLs. It automatically adds canonical URLs for most of the pages on your website or WordPress blog. Otherwise, you can also filter the output of the canonical URL of WordPress programmatically.

Noindex tool

The Noindex tool is used in SEO to prevent search engine crawlers from indexing a web page, meaning it won’t appear in search engine results. It’s typically used for pages that aren’t meant to be indexed.

In the case of All in One SEO, Noindex Settings has been replaced by the new Show in Search Results settings under Search Appearance in version 4.x of All in One SEO. The documentation for Noindex settings can be found in Showing or Hiding Your Content in Search Results.

Yoast SEO, on the other hand, comes with a hidden feature due to which the internal search pages of your site are set to noindex by default. This setting is not editable since it follows Google Guidelines. However, if you still want to change it, you can use one of the platform’s filters to do so.

Winner: All in One SEO

In terms of facilitating link management, All in One SEO stands out for its greater number of features and better functionality.

Tracking and analytics

Moving on to the next comparison, let’s discuss tracking and analytics. where we’ll compare two popular tools and see how they differ in their approach.

Insights/analytics dashboard

All in One SEO provides a powerful analytics dashboard that allows you to track key metrics such as organic search traffic, pageviews, bounce rate, and more. You can view data for specific periods and compare metrics to see how your website performs over time. 

Additionally, you can use All in One SEO’s analytics dashboard to monitor how your website’s search engine rankings are impacting your traffic and user behavior. In contrast, Yoast SEO analytics does not offer an insights dashboard in its plugin. 

While it does provide some basic analytics features, such as tracking search appearance and pageviews directly within the WordPress dashboard, Yoast content analysis remains a primary focus. Therefore, if advanced tracking and analytics features are important to you, All in One SEO may be the better choice.

Rank tracker

Both plugins offer rank-tracking features, but there are some key differences between the two. All in One SEO offers rank tracking for unlimited keywords, while Yoast only allows you to track up to 5 keywords per week with its Wincher integration in the free plan.

Another key difference is that All in One SEO provides detailed reports on your ranking progress, while Yoast only shows your current ranking position. Overall, both plugins offer similar rank-tracking features. However, All in One SEO provides more detailed data and reports, making it the better choice for serious WordPress users who want to monitor their SEO progress closely.

Winner: All in One SEO

Both plugins provide exceptional tracking and analytics features. However, All in One SEO gives you more control over your analytics data.

Integrations

Regarding SEO tools, integrations can make all the difference. You need tools that seamlessly integrate with your existing workflows to get the most out of your SEO efforts. Let’s examine the integration capabilities of these two tools.

Integrations to other SEO tools

Both plugins offer many options regarding integrations with other SEO and analytics tools. All in One SEO integrates with tools such as Google Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools, Ahrefs, SEMrush, Majestic, Yoast SEO, and Moz, allowing users to analyze, optimize, and monitor their website’s performance with ease. 

Integrations in All in One SEO

Yoast also provides robust integrations, including Zapier, SEMrush, Wincher, Elementor, ACF fields, Algolia, WordProof, and Jetpack. You can also access Yoast WooCommerce SEO, Easy Digital Downloads, and Mastodon to help users connect their website to various tools and platforms for a comprehensive SEO strategy. 

Integrations in Yoast

However, Yoast also offers the unique feature of Local SEO support, which can benefit businesses that want to improve their online presence in specific locations.

Integrations to analytics tools

Both All in One SEO and Yoast offer integrations to popular analytics platforms such as Google Analytics, allowing you to track important metrics such as website traffic, user behavior, and conversions. In addition, All in One SEO integrates with popular marketing automation tools like HubSpot and Salesforce, which can be particularly useful for businesses that rely heavily on sales and marketing. 

Yoast also offers integration with Google Analytics, which can provide valuable insights into your website’s performance and help you make data-driven decisions about your SEO strategy.

Optimized for WooCommerce

For WordPress users running an e-commerce website with WooCommerce, both plugins offer integrations that optimize your website for search engines and improve the visibility of your products in search results. However, All in One SEO provides a more comprehensive set of features to help you boost your e-commerce SEO efforts.

Optimization for WooCommerce in All in One SEO

All in One SEO WooCommerce integration includes features such as product schema markup, which helps search engines understand the information on your product pages, and automatic generation of meta tags and titles for your products based on their attributes. This saves you time and effort in optimizing your product pages for search engines.

When comparing All in One SEO vs Yoast, it’s important to note that while Yoast offers some basic SEO features for e-commerce websites, its WooCommerce integration is not as comprehensive as that of All in One SEO. Yoast may be suitable for smaller e-commerce businesses or simpler SEO needs, but All in One SEO’s WooCommerce integration is a better choice for those with more complex requirements.

Optimization for WooCommerce in Yoast

Local SEO support

When comparing All in One SEO vs Yoast, both plugins support local SEO for local businesses. All in One SEO offers more advanced local SEO features, such as local business schema markup and a local SEO module for optimized local content.

Yoast also offers local SEO support, but its features are more limited than All in One SEO. Its local SEO features include setting your business address and phone number and generating a Google Maps embed code for your website. However, it fails to offer advanced features such as local business Yoast schema markup.

Overall, if local SEO is a key priority for your website, All in One SEO may be the better choice due to its advanced local SEO features and dedicated local SEO module. But if you only need basic local SEO support, Yoast may be sufficient for your needs.

Winner: It’s a Tie!

In our battle of All in One SEO vs Yoast, both plugins provide great integration features, which makes it difficult to determine a clear winner in this aspect. Therefore, it can be considered a tie between the two plugins. 

As seen, both plugins have their strengths and weaknesses. However, what if it was told that a new plugin solves some of Yoast’s main issues? The AI Assistant from 10Web is capable of fixing SEO and readability errors in Yoast SEO. Advanced algorithms and machine learning techniques are used by the AI Assistant to optimize the website content to meet the highest SEO standards and ensure that the content is easy to read and engaging for the audience. This tool can be a valuable addition for those who use Yoast SEO and want to improve their website’s overall performance.

Get Started for Free No credit card required
video poster
Generate Your Website No credit card required

Pricing and value summary: which one is the right choice for you?

When it comes to choosing the right SEO plugin for your WordPress site, both All in One SEO and Yoast are excellent choices. These plugins take much of the guesswork and tedium out of optimizing your content and improving your search engine rankings. 

However, if you’re deciding between All in One SEO vs Yoast, it’s important to consider the specific features and functionality each plugin offers.

When it comes to choosing between All in One SEO vs Yoast, both plugins offer impressive features that can enhance your website’s search engine optimization efforts. All in One SEO offers advanced features such as video sitemaps, while Yoast excels in content analysis and readability. Ultimately, it’s up to you to determine which plugin best fits your needs. 

FAQ

Can I use Yoast and All in One SEO together?

It’s rather better to choose one plugin and use it consistently for your SEO efforts. Using both together on the same website is not recommended; it can lead to unnecessary duplication of efforts and even harm your website’s SEO performance.

Does All in One SEO slow down your website more than Yoast?

No. Both All in One SEO and Yoast are well-coded and optimized for speed, so their impact on website performance is usually minimal. However, enabling many features and options in either plugin can potentially slow down your website.

How do I move from All in One SEO to Yoast SEO?

Follow these steps for this –

  • Deactivate All in One SEO
  • Create a backup of your website
  • Go to the Yoast SEO plugin’s “Import from other SEO plugins” page under the “Tools” menu
  • Choose “All in One SEO” as the plugin you want to import from and click the “Import” button
  • Check that your data is imported and go through the first-time configuration
  • Once you’ve confirmed that everything is working properly, click the “Clean” button to remove any leftover data from All in One SEO.

How do I move from Yoast to All in One SEO?

Follow these steps to move from Yoast to All in One SEO –

  • Go to the All in One SEO plugin and navigate to the “Tools” section.
  • Click on “Import/Export” and then select “Import Settings From Other Plugins”.
  • Choose “Yoast” as the plugin you want to import from.
  • Click on the “Import” button to begin the migration process.
  • Once the import is complete, all of your Yoast settings will be migrated to All in One SEO.

Are Yoast or All in One SEO enough to handle all SEO tasks?

While both are powerful SEO plugins with many features, they cannot handle all SEO tasks. It’s important to supplement their use with other SEO practices and monitor website performance through analytics tools.
Share article

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your email address will never be published or shared. Required fields are marked *

Comment*

Name *

1 comments

  • David Dràbek

    Thanks a lot for the comprehensive analysis and comparision of the plugins. It was exactly what I needed!

    Loading
    Copy